Learn about what the STF says regarding the taxation of bank deposits

The Supreme Federal Court (“STF”), in the records of Extraordinary Appeal (“RE”) No. 855,649, decided on the constitutionality of income tax (“IR”) on amounts deposited in the taxpayers’ current account, when they, after being summoned, they are unable to prove the origin of such values.

The case originated in the Federal Regional Court of the 4th Region (“TRF4”), which stated that article 42 of Law No. 9,430 / 96 was constitutional. This article provides, in summary, that when a taxpayer, upon being summoned by the tax authorities to provide the origin of a value deposited in an account with the financial institution, fails to prove this origin, he would be practicing an omission of revenue or income.

In the case of TRF4, the taxpayers were a couple who worked with a kind of factoring, in which the financial transactions in the current account, which were joint, resulted from checks, bonds and money from customers. Thus, the taxpayers’ claim was that the amounts moved in the current account were in fact not their property.

However, after a subpoena from the Federal Revenue Service (“RFB”), the taxpayers were unsuccessful in their claim, since the origin of the amounts could not be demonstrated satisfactorily.

According to the Attorney General’s Office of the National Treasury (“PGFN”), Article 42 of Law No. 9,430 / 96 does not impose a tax on bank deposits, but rather allows a tax increase on what the taxpayer will pay, if there is no proof of the opposite.

The vote on the issue in the STF was the subject of disagreement. On the one hand, Minister Marco Aurélio understood that it cannot not be assumed that all taxpayers are tax evaders, and that Article 42 of Law No. 9,430 / 96 would be incompatible with the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Brazil (“CRFB / 88”) .

However, the winning vote was that of Minister Alexandre de Moraes. According to him, the aforementioned Law did not extend to the taxable event. In his opinion, “(…) it would be enough for the taxpayer to make a mere allegation that the deposits made in his current account belongs to third parties, without relieving himself of the burden of proving the veracity of his declaration” for an attempt to be made to evade the obligations of paying income tax.

Camila Cabral, tax advisor at Drummond Advisors, gave her opinion on the decision. “The assessments based on bank transactions and deposits grew relatively after the transfer of information between financial institutions and the RFB was allowed in 2016. The STF decision, imposing the burden of proof to the taxpayer on bank transactions, can cause situations of insecurity to the taxpayers, due to the fact that certain transactions are subject to the RFB’s scrutiny. It is often possible to prove the origin of a particular resource, but the RFB may not accept the proof ”, she commented.

“As an example, the loan and the loan agreement are cited. Regarding the loan, specifically, regardless of the amount it is a transaction between private individuals, the RFB only accepts loan agreements registered with a notary as a suitable proof. However, the Public Records Law itself lists the loan as a transaction that does not need to be registered”, added the consultant.

Share

Let's talk?

Related news

The Importance of English as a Second Language

In today’s globalized world, English proficiency as a second language has become an invaluable asset in the professional arena. The ability to communicate effectively in English can significantly improve career prospects, foster international collaboration, and open up a multitude of opportunities across various industries. This article delves into the reasons why mastering English is crucial for professionals and how it can impact their career trajectories. 1. Global Communication and Collaboration English is often referred to as the “lingua franca” of the modern world. According to the British Council, English is spoken at a decent level by 1.75 billion people worldwide – that’s one in every four of us. In the professional setting, this translates as a common ground for individuals from diverse backgrounds, facilitating clear and effective communication. Renowned institutions such as Harvard University emphasize the importance of English proficiency for professionals working in multinational corporations, international organizations, and global markets. Harvard’s Division of Continuing Education highlights that “English is the language of international business and trade, making it essential for professionals to communicate across borders”. 2. Access to Knowledge and Resources The majority of the world’s academic papers, research, and professional literature are published in English. For professionals in fields such as science, technology, medicine, and finance, proficiency in English enables access to the latest research findings, technical manuals, and industry reports. This access is critical for staying current with advancements and maintaining a competitive edge. The University of Cambridge notes that “English is the dominant language of the internet and of the world’s leading scientific journals”. Thus, professionals with strong English skills can access key information that is not readily available in other languages. 3. Career Advancement and Opportunities Employers across the globe prioritize candidates who can demonstrate strong English communication skills. According to a report by EF Education First, companies often see English proficiency as a key factor in hiring, promotions, and international assignments. The report states that “employees with good English are often better positioned for leadership roles and are more likely to be selected for international projects and business trips”. Universities like Oxford emphasize that “the ability to speak English can lead to higher salaries and better job positions, as many employers value bilingual employees who can navigate different markets and cultures”. 4. Cultural Competence and Diversity Understanding and communicating in English also increases cultural competence and the ability to work in diverse teams. English often acts as a bridge that connects people from various cultures, helping the development of healthy team dynamics. This cultural competence is particularly important in professions that require collaboration across different countries and cultures. Stanford University highlights that “professionals who are proficient in English are better equipped to understand and respect cultural differences, which is essential in today’s multicultural work environment”. 5. Innovation and Creativity English proficiency can also drive innovation and creativity within organizations. When professionals from different parts of the world can communicate effectively, they can share ideas, challenge each other’s thinking, and collaborate on innovative solutions. The ability to share one’s ideas clearly and constructively is vital for fostering a culture of creativity and continuous improvement. MIT Sloan School of Management notes that “global teams that communicate in a common language like English are more likely to engage in creative problem-solving and innovation”. In summary, the importance of English as a second language in a professional setting cannot be overstated. From enhancing global communication and access to knowledge to improving career prospects and fostering innovation, English proficiency is a crucial skill for today’s professionals. Renowned universities and educational institutions universally acknowledge the benefits of English in advancing one’s career and facilitating international collaboration. As the world continues to become more interconnected, the ability to communicate in English will remain a key driver of professional success and personal growth. By understanding and embracing the significance of English in the professional world, individuals can unlock new opportunities, enhance their career prospects, and contribute meaningfully to the global community. If you want to start learning or even improve your English Level, you can visit https://www.campus.live/. Written by Campus Live References: 1. Harvard University, Division of Continuing Education. (n.d.). “The Importance of English in International Business.” 2. University of Cambridge. (n.d.). “English as a Global Language.” 3. EF Education First. (2023). “EF English Proficiency Index.” 4. University of Oxford. (n.d.). “Benefits of English Proficiency.” 5. Stanford University. (n.d.). “Cultural Competence and Communication.” 6. MIT Sloan School of Management. (n.d.). “Innovation through Multilingual Communication.”

Read More »

The Permeation of English in Brazilian Business

In recent years, English has increasingly become a pivotal element in the Brazilian business landscape. As globalization accelerates and Brazil strengthens its position in the international market, English proficiency has emerged as a crucial skill for professionals across various industries. This article explores how English has permeated Brazilian business and the benefits it brings to companies and individuals alike. 1. Global Market Access Brazilian companies are expanding their reach beyond national borders, engaging in trade, partnerships, and investments worldwide. English serves as the bridge language in these international dealings. According to the Brazilian National Confederation of Industry (CNI), proficiency in English is essential for companies aiming to compete globally. It allows Brazilian businesses to effectively communicate with foreign partners, negotiate contracts, and understand international market trends. 2. Enhancing Professional Opportunities For Brazilian professionals, English opens doors to a wealth of career opportunities. A study by the British Council in Brazil indicates that individuals with strong English skills have higher employability and can access better job positions and salaries. Many multinational corporations operating in Brazil prioritize hiring bilingual employees who can navigate both local and international contexts. 3. Access to Knowledge and Innovation English is the predominant language of global research and development. Brazilian professionals proficient in English can access cutting-edge research, technological advancements, and industry best practices that are often published in English. This access is crucial for fostering innovation and maintaining competitiveness in the global market. The São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) emphasizes that English proficiency is vital for participating in international conferences, publishing research, and collaborating on global projects. 4. Cultural Exchange and Diversity English proficiency also facilitates cultural exchange and enhances the ability to work in diverse environments. As Brazil hosts and participates in numerous international events, such as the Olympic Games and the World Cup, English allows for smoother interactions and richer cultural experiences. This cultural competence is beneficial in fostering a more inclusive and dynamic business environment. The permeation of English in Brazilian business is a testament to the country’s integration into the global economy. As Brazilian companies and professionals continue to embrace English, they unlock new opportunities, drive innovation, and enhance their competitive edge on the world stage. By investing in English language education and training, Brazil is poised to further solidify its role as a key player in the international business community. Through the mastery of English, Brazilian businesses and professionals can look forward to a future of expanded horizons and greater success in the global marketplace. To start or improve your English learning process, visit https://www.campus.live/pt-br/. Written by Campus Live References: 1. Brazilian National Confederation of Industry (CNI). (n.d.). “The Importance of English for International Business.” 2. British Council Brazil. (n.d.). “English Language Skills and Employability.” 3. São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP). (n.d.). “Global Research and Collaboration.”

Read More »

The importance of internal regulations for the company’s legal certainty

Labor relations are generally regulated by the Federal Constitution and the Consolidation of Labor Laws – CLT. However, it is common for several situations not to be expressly provided for in labor legislation, raising doubts about the procedures to be adopted by companies when faced with these situations. As legislation does not follow the evolution of labor relations, these gaps can (and should) be filled through the preparation of Internal Regulations, which must be drawn up in a clear and transparent manner, bringing greater legal certainty to the company. What are the Internal Regulations? The internal regulations consist of a set of rules that will govern the company’s internal organization, establishing rights and obligations between the company and employees. Thus, the main function of the internal regulations is to structure, in clear rules, the company’s reality in its work relationships. What are the advantages of the Internal Regulations? By establishing clear internal rules, the internal regulations will make employees aware of the company’s culture, their obligations and duties, making it easier to manage people. What can be provided for in the Internal Regulations? In general, the internal regulations can provide for all the duties and obligations of employees, such as: What happens if the Internal Regulations are not complied with? The internal regulations themselves may establish penalties in case of non-compliance with the established rules. However, penalties must be based on reasonableness and proportional to the non-compliance identified. Can the Internal Regulations be changed by the company? Yes, they can be changed freely by the company. However, any changes must be communicated to employees. Do the Internal Regulations require participation from the Union?  There is no requirement in the law regarding the participation of unions in the preparation of internal regulations. As seen, the internal regulations are an important tool for internal organization and labor compliance, providing greater legal security to the company and awareness among the group of employees. If you have questions about the subject, contact our experts. Written by Daniel Rangel, Associate at Drummond Advisors

Read More »

Who must file income tax returns in Brazil in 2024?

The IRPF is an important tax obligation for many Brazilians, and understanding who must file an income tax returns in Brazil in 2024 is key to avoiding complications with the Receita Federal. The period for submitting the annual IRPF (Individual Income Tax) return runs until May 31st. Federal Revenue Service expects to receive 43 million returns this year. Those who fail to submit their tax return by the deadline may face a minimum fine of R$165.74. This amount can reach up to 20% of the amount of income tax due. Check out who must file an income tax returns in Brazil in 2024 Do you have any questions or need help submitting your IRPF 2024 tax return in Brazil? Get in touch with us via the available chat or email info@drummondadvisors.com. Written by Marcos Ferreira, Content Analyst at Drummond Advisors

Read More »

Bank accounts and financial investments outside the US must be declared: get to know FBAR

Individuals and legal entities who are domiciled in the United States or who are fiscal residents of the country and have a direct or indirect interest in financial accounts or financial applications outside the US need to be aware of another obligation due to the Internal Revenue Service: it is mandatory to complete and submit the Report of Foreign Bank Accounts and Financial Accounts, the FBAR, until April 15. Who is subjected to FBAR The obligation applies to those who have final interest or signature authority over financial accounts or investments outside the US territory whose added value is equal to or greater than US$ 10,000.00. Signature authority is the authority that an individual (alone or in conjunction with another individual) has to control assets held in a foreign financial account by means of direct communication (either in writing or otherwise) with the bank or other financial institution which maintains that account. The financial account includes, but is not limited to, securities, brokerage, savings, demand, checking, deposit, time deposit or other account maintained with a financial institution (or person performing the services of a financial institution). A financial account also includes a commodity futures or options account,  an insurance policy with cash value (such as a whole life insurance policy), an annuity policy with cash value and shares in a mutual fund or similar pooled fund (a fund that is available to the general public). Deadline The deadline for submitting the form to the IRS is April 15 of each year. If it is not delivered by this day, the deadline is automatically extended to October 15. Penalties Penalties for failing to deliver the statement or providing incomplete or incorrect information may amount to US$ 100,000.00 or 50% of account balances (whichever is greater). Need help declaring the FBAR or are you still having doubts? Contact us at info@drummondadvisors.com

Read More »

Payroll in the US: frequency of salary payments

Payment frequencies in the US (Payroll Schedule or Payroll Frequency) vary and directly influence the financial management of companies and the financial stability of employees. Main frequencies are: Quarterly – every 3 months; The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) establishes some guidelines on payment frequencies. However, specific regulations may vary from state to state. For example, in Florida, state laws may influence the frequency of pay, with some requirements specific to certain industries or types of work. Generally, WEEKLY and BIWEEKLY pay frequencies are more common for operational positions. Turnover is higher and frequent pay can be an incentive in these cases. The SEMIMONTHLY, MONTHLY and QUARTERLY frequencies are more common in management positions or higher salaries, providing a different financial vision and more strategic planning. Frequency and date of Payroll in the USA The date of payment is also determined by the company, always following state laws and regulations. Employees need to know the established frequency of their pay already on admission – which can be changed with everyone’s consent and agreement. The variation usually happens in the MONTHLY and SEMIMONTHLY frequencies, as the payment date may not fall on a business day, and the recommendation is to advance the date to the nearest business day. Determining the Payout Frequency for a business is not a simple decision. It involves financial, legal, and even cultural considerations. It takes into account the company’s financial health, compliance with local regulations, employee needs and even administrative efficiency. Understanding these frequencies is crucial for businesses and employees as it directly impacts cash flow, personal financial planning, and even talent retention. State Payday Requirements – https://lnkd.in/dcUrZnRP Written by Adriano Nogueira, Personal Department Analyst at Drummond Advisors

Read More »

Estimated Taxes for Individuals

What are Estimated Taxes? Taxes need to be paid as we earn or receive income throughout the year. In general, they are already retained as soon as this income is generated. However, if they are not sufficiently retained at their origins, or not at all, it is necessary to estimate these taxes due and make the corresponding payment. It is important to pay attention to income, dividends, pensions, capital gains and prizes that may not have withheld taxes. These are the so-called Estimated Taxes that not only occur for income, but must also be paid in relation to the Self-Employment Tax (for example, freelancers, people who own their own business or work under independent contracts) and the Alternative Minimum Tax (which applies to individuals who have a high economic income). Who must or must not pay? Who must pay: Who must not pay: * Not having a tax obligation in the previous tax year means that you did not have taxes due or did not need to file a statement. When must they be paid? (Pay as you go, so you won’t owe) In order to meet tax needs, the year is divided into four different periods and each of them has a specific payment date. Payment dates are predetermined in the year prior to the current tax period.For a better understanding, 2023 is an example of a current tax year in which four payment dates are stipulated. The first payment was set for April 18th, the second for June 15th, 2022, the third for September 15th of the same year and the last for January 16th, 2024. Remembering that these dates may vary each year.It is important to note that if payment is sent using the United States Postal Service, the date of payment of Estimated Taxes will be considered to be the date of mailing of the package. Additionally, if the date falls on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, payment will still be on time if made exactly on the next business day. How to pay? 1) Post Office:Sent a check or cash order through the United States Postal Service using Form 1040-ES, which applies to US citizens and tax residents, (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040es.pdf) or Form 1040-ES(NR), which applies to non-tax residents (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040esn.pdf).With this payment method, it is important to be aware of the shipping details as specified by the Internal Revenue Service – IRS (https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-by-check-or-money-order). 2) Registration on the IRS website:Online through an account registered on the IRS website (https://www.irs.gov/payments/your-online-account). The website may also be accessed by cell phone or using an application available for IOS and Android systems (https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs2goapp). 3) Bank Account:Online through a direct payment into your checking or savings account, at no additional cost and without registration required (https://www.irs.gov/payments/direct-pay). 4) Digital Card or Wallet:Online using a debit or credit card, or using a digital wallet, such as PayPal. This payment will have additional costs that may vary depending on the payment method chosen. Fees are specified on the website (https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-your-taxes-by-debit-or-credit-card). 5) Electronic Federal Tax Payment System – EFTPS:Online through the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System – EFTPS, a system developed by the U.S. Department of Treasury itself in which, after having your credentials released, you can make any necessary payments relating to federal taxes (https://www.eftps.gov/eftps/). 6) Eletronic Funds Withdrawal – e-fillling:Through an integrated system that will electronically withdraw funds from a bank account appointed on your Tax Return. This option is only available when the tax is prepared and sent using software or when done by a tax professional (https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-taxes-by-electronic-funds-withdrawal). 7) Same-Day Wire:It is possible to make a scheduled transfer at your financial institution by contacting them to check availability, costs and limits (https://www.irs.gov/payments/same-day-wire-federal-tax-payments). 8) Cash:If, for some reason, it is necessary to pay in cash, you must remember that it should never be sent by the post office. Therefore, IRS provides some officially listed partners and assistance centers that are qualified to receive this type of payment (https://www.irs.gov/payments/pay-your-taxes-with-cash). Are there penalties for those who do not pay? A fine may be applied if payments during the year were not sufficient, either because the required amount of taxes was not withheld or Estimated Taxes were not paid.

Read More »

The STJ rules on the taxation of the PLR of company directors and managers

The Superior Court of Justice (STJ) has ruled for the first time on a case that could have a major impact on the taxation of the PLR of company directors and managers in the country. Profit Sharing (PLR) is a financial incentive program used by many companies as a way of rewarding their employees based on the company’s performance and financial results. It is a benefit that aims to motivate employees to dedicate themselves to the success of the organization, since they share in the profits or positive results achieved. However, the taxation of PLR, especially when it comes to directors and managers, has been a controversial issue in Brazilian courts. Questions such as whether or not PLR should be taxed and what the criteria for taxation are have been a source of uncertainty for companies. STJ ruling on the taxation of directors’ and officers’ PLR The STJ has ruled for the first time on the issue of the taxation of directors’ and officers’ PLR. Justice Sérgio Kukina, the rapporteur of the case, voted against the taxation of private pension payments, but in favor of PLR. Justice Gurgel de Faria then asked to be heard in order to make a more in-depth analysis of the issue, due to the novelty of the case. He will now have 90 days to return the case. Three other ministers will also be able to vote. The STJ ruling is an important milestone in Brazilian tax law. The court’s decision will provide guidelines on an issue that has been the subject of discussion and litigation for a long time. Written by Marcos Ferreira, Content Assistant at Drummond Advisors Read also: https://drummondadvisors.com/2023/10/05/comecou-o-julgamento-antitruste-do-google-nos-estados-unidos/

Read More »

“Grandchildren’s Law” makes it easier to obtain Spanish Citizenship

The Democratic Memorial Law, also known as the ” Grandchildren’s Law”, is a new Spanish legislation that facilitates the access to recognize the Spanish citizenship for a certain period, which ends on 10/21/2024 (with the possibility of extension until 10/21/2025). The current Spanish Citizenship Law, enforced since 2007, only allowed the sons and daughters of Spaniards, as well as grandchildren below 18 years old, to apply for recognition of Spanish citizenship, which made it impossible for grandchildren who were of legal age, or with deceased parents who had not become Spaniards, to have their own Spanish citizenship recognized. With the Democratic Memorial Law, named so because it aims to benefit relatives of victims of the Spanish Civil War and the Francoist Dictatorship, grandchildren of legal age are now allowed to have their citizenship recognized, even if their parents, already deceased, have not obtained such recognition. In this way, thousands of grandchildren of Spaniards, now have the possibility of recognition of citizenship. Nevertheless, the Law provides for another important benefit: If any person has citizenship recognized by this Law, their adult children may also apply for recognition of citizenship, which also allows thousands of Spaniards descendants be recognized as Spanish citizens. Finally, another important change is that the Law now allows the children of Spanish women who married before 08/29/1978 to obtain recognition of citizenship, which was not allowed previously. This is because before this date, Spanish women who married foreigners lost their nationality, preventing them from passing it on to their children. In this sense, many children of Spanish women will also be able to apply for citizenship. But beware: the deadline for applications for recognition to be made is October 21st, 2024. Are you interested in recognizing your Spanish Citizenship and enjoying the benefits of a European Passport? Contact our Global Mobility team at Drummond Advisors! Written by Eduardo Giugliano, Associate at Drummond Advisors

Read More »

The Regulation of Virtual Assets in Brazil: Everything You Need to Know About Cryptocurrency Trading in the Country

In December of 2022, the Brazilian Federal Law No 14.478/2022 entered into force to establish a regulation on virtual assets, such as cryptocurrency, in Brazil. The cryptocurrency matter was unregulated in Brazil until the Brazilian Federal Law No 14.478 was established, which has left investors and crypto exchange companies uncertain of the provisions that should be taken into consideration to trade digital assets in the country in the past. The Brazilian Federal Law No 14.478, also known as Cryptocurrency Legal Milestone (in Portuguese, Marco Legal das Criptomoedas), establishes some definitions for important terms regarding the cryptocurrency matter, the principles that should be observed by virtual assets service providers (the term used by the law to refer to crypto exchange companies) and the activities that the regulating competent governmental organization will be responsible for. Here are some important provisions of the Law that you should know: Also, the Cryptocurrency Legal Milestone expressly establishes that its provisions are not applicable to virtual assets that can be defined as securities, according to the definition provided by the Brazilian Securities Commission. Also, in June of 2023, the Brazilian Federal Decree No 11.563/2023 entered into force to determine that the competent governmental organization responsible for regulating and supervising cryptocurrency trading in Brazil will be the Central Bank of Brazil (in Portuguese, Banco Central do Brasil). Since then, the Central Bank of Brazil has been working on drafting and publishing an official regulation on virtual assets trading but, until the date of publication of this newsletter, this regulation has not yet been published. This does not mean that other Brazilian governmental organizations could not be involved in cryptocurrency operations in any way. The Cryptocurrency Legal Milestone expressly indicates that the Brazilian Securities Commission (in Portuguese, Comissão de Valores Mobiliários – CVM) will be responsible to regulate every transaction that involves virtual assets that can be defined as securities (in Portuguese, valores mobiliários). The Brazilian Securities Commission has already published, in October of 2022, an Orientation document (in Portuguese, the Parecer de Orientação CVM n° 40) with some recommendations for exchange crypto companies that want to trade crypto as securities in Brazil. Also, the Cryptocurrency Legal Milestone defines that the Brazilian Consumer’s Defense Code (in Portuguese, Código de Defesa do Consumidor) will be applicable to the relationship between virtual assets service providers and its clients, which means that the governmental organization Consumer’s Protection and Defense Program (in Portuguese, Programa de Proteção e Defesa do Consumidor – Procon) can also be involved in virtual assets operations, to mediate conflicts between the virtual assets service providers and its clients. The Cryptocurrency Legal Milestone and the Decree No 11.563/2023 were a big step into the regulation of virtual assets trading in Brazil, but this matter is yet to be complemented by the Brazilian Central Bank’s regulation, which has not yet been published, and which will determine the rules and provisions that virtual assets service providers should follow to get an authorization to act as a virtual assets service provider in Brazil. Written by Mariana Tavares and Mariana Belisario

Read More »

Tax Reform on consumption in Brazil 

On December 21, 2023, Constitutional Amendment n. 132 was published, which amends the tax system on consumption in Brazil.  The main change consists of replacing the taxes currently levied on consumption (PIS/COFINS/IPI/ICMS/ISS) with a Dual Value Added Tax (VAT) levied on goods and services and a Selective Tax (IS). Main features of VAT Dual:  Selective Tax  Cash back  Special Tax Regimes  Manaus Free Zone   Simples Nacional (SN)  Particularities regarding ICMS  Validated ICMS Benefits   Credit balances  Transition to the new model   Taxation of Income and Assets  Drummond Advisors is available to assist in the assessment of potential impacts arising from the consumption tax reform in Brazil. 

Read More »
Scroll to Top
Search